In their prime, would you trade Barry Bonds for Clayton Kershaw? I’m talking in their prime. Not today. Not yesterday. Not 25 years ago. In the prime of their careers. 

We all know the Dodgers and Giants hate each other in the worst way. So take Bonds when he took steroids and take Kershaw in his Cy Young years. It’s a very debatable question as you’re trading a big time hitter for a lights out dominate pitcher. It boils down to what does your team need at the moment. A power bat or a 20 game winner? 

Would you make this trade?